Blue Eyed Six & The Faith – Chp 13 (Zechman Re-Trial)

Blue Eyed Poster

GLEANED FROM THE BLUE EYED SIX BOOKS BY Edna Carmean & Wayne H. Anspach: A true story from the late 19th century about four men who insured the town hobo and then hired a humble butcher and local ruffian to murder him so they could collect the insurance money…. all six having blue eyes!

ZECHMAN’s RE-TRIAL was held November 7, 1879. It was amazing that George Zechman slipped the hangman’s noose but he did. He was seen as a member of “the four” many times at Israel Brandt’s hotel. He was even at the creek after Raber was drowned. He also met with the insurance man to sign the death proof forms in order to collect his money! So why did he get off? The legend passed down through the years is hat he hired a slick lawyer and guess what? He did! Sixty-four year old Francis Wade Huges from Pottsville was hired and the country bumpkin attorneys of Lebanon County were just no match for this formidable court adversary. He was reared with cultural advantages which conferred a stature denied the sons of the Pennsylvania Dutch dirt farmers. He started studying law at seventeen, was admitted to the bar when he was twenty, and had a highly successful law practice. He also served eleven years as deputy attorney general and was white-haired and handsome and exuded a powerful courtroom presence.

Henry Wise who was the first to confess to the crime was the Commonwealth’s star witness against Zechman and ended up being Attorney Hughes first victim. Hughes picked Wise apart like a vulture over a roadside skeleton. Wise testified that he told Charles Drews and others on many occasions that he didn’t want Raber drowned but through the piercing questioning of Hughes, it was revealed that no one but Wise ever could substantiate that statement. It apparently never happened and as that statement was disproved Wise’s whole testimony against the others began to unravel and the thought that Zechman may be innocent began to take hold. Hughes also proved that though Zechman might have purchased insurance on Raber, which was legal, he was never seen encouraging Stichler or Drews to commit the crime like the others were. Other than the word of the other defendants, no one testified that Zechman was in on the plotting of Raber’s death.

Here’s an example of Hughes argument in the courtroom from Edna Carmean’s Blue Eyed Six book: Francis Wade Huges approached the twelve men in the jury box and surveyed them silently for a few moments. An impressive figure with his keen dark eyes, white hair and solid bulk, he dominated the room like an actor in his favorite role. His resonant voice and immaculate diction added to the effect. “You have no right,” he said quietly, “to rely on the testimony of Henry wise. He is a convicted accomplice, and he testifies here to save his own neck! I have tried many men accused of crimes, and I never asked a jury to convict a single man upon the evidence of an accomplice unless he was corroborated in every material instance.” Huges raised his right hand in a fist and looked along the line of jurors. “There is no human eye,” he thundered, “and I suspect not even the All-Seeing Eye, that ever saw Zechman in communication with Drews. You have not a single iota of testimony showing that Zechman ever spoke to Stichler or Drews prior to the murder of Raber.”

Others testified for and against Zechman but the above argument was the most powerful and so it prevailed. On November 13, 1879 eleven months after the crime was committed, George Zechman was found not guilty. Zechman’s attorney gave a shout of joy and burst into tears and threw his arms around Zechman’s shoulders. Zechman stood motionless without any change of expression. He was dismissed from the court room and was met out on the street by his wife and a group of friends who drove him to his home in the mountains, and to the obscurity he had ardently desired during his long months in the public limelight. Local legend in subsequent years says that he lived a tormented life and had excruciating boils break out on his body time and time again until he met his Maker just 7 short years later, dying at the young age of forty-seven.

Once Zechman’s trial was over the wheels of justice moved quickly forward for Charles Drews and Franklin Stichler. In the afternoon, after Zechman was freed, Sheriff Deininger visited Drews and Stichler in their cells to give them bad news. Their lawyers were unsuccessful in getting them a reprieve from Governor Hoyt. A telegram was received from him that stated he would not interfere with the executions and so they would be hanged soon after 10 o’clock the next morning! Stichler said, “I am ready.” Drews said, “Let it be so.” Then added, “Just one thing Sheriff, do a good job.”


THE BIBLE: Seek the Lord while He may be found, Call upon Him while He is near. Let the wicked forsake his way, And the unrighteous man his thoughts; Let him return to the LordAnd He will have mercy on him; And to our God, For He will abundantly pardon” (Isaiah 55:6-7 NKJV)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s